Plant Physiol. (1998) 118: 1447-1454
Direct Measurement of Calcium Transport across Chloroplast
Inner-Envelope Vesicles1
Michael H. Roh,
Richard Shingles,
Michael J. Cleveland, and
Richard
E. McCarty*
Department of Biology, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore,
Maryland 21218-2685
 |
ABSTRACT |
The initial rate of Ca2+
movement across the inner-envelope membrane of pea (Pisum
sativum L.) chloroplasts was directly measured by stopped-flow
spectrofluorometry using membrane vesicles loaded with the
Ca2+-sensitive fluorophore fura-2. Calibration of fura-2
fluorescence was achieved by combining a ratiometric method with
Ca2+-selective minielectrodes to determine pCa values. The
initial rate of Ca2+ influx in predominantly right-side-out
inner-envelope membrane vesicles was greater than that in largely
inside-out vesicles. Ca2+ movement was stimulated by an
inwardly directed electrochemical proton gradient across the membrane
vesicles, an effect that was diminished by the addition of valinomycin
in the presence of K+. In addition, Ca2+ was
shown to move across the membrane vesicles in the presence of a
K+ diffusion potential gradient. The potential-stimulated
rate of Ca2+ transport was slightly inhibited by diltiazem
and greatly inhibited by ruthenium red. Other pharmacological agents
such as LaCl3, verapamil, and nifedipine had little or no
effect. These results indicate that Ca2+ transport across
the chloroplast inner envelope can occur by a potential-stimulated
uniport mechanism.
 |
INTRODUCTION |
Ca2+ in plant cells has many key
physiological functions; for example, as an intracellular second
messenger it is especially important for the maintenance of cellular
homeostasis and signal transduction pathways (Evans et al., 1991
;
Pineros and Tester, 1997
). Therefore, the
[Ca2+]cyt must be
strictly regulated. The sequestration of Ca2+
into endomembrane compartments has been documented in detail for the ER
and the vacuole (Evans et al., 1991
). The chloroplast may also serve as
a potential Ca2+ sink (Brand and Becker, 1984
;
Evans et al., 1991
).
In addition to the potential role of chloroplasts in maintaining
low resting [Ca2+]cyt, it
has been proposed that the free [Ca2+] in the
stroma regulates several key enzymes involved in photosynthetic CO2 assimilation, including
Fru-1,6-bisphosphatase and sedoheptulose-1,7-bisphosphatase (Kreimer et
al., 1988
) and NAD+ kinase (Brand and Becker,
1984
). Ca2+ is also essential for
O2 evolution by PSII (Grove and Brudvig, 1998
).
Although the role of Ca2+ in the stroma and
thylakoids has been studied in detail (Brand and Becker, 1984
), there
have been relatively few investigations on Ca2+
uptake by chloroplasts.
One study examining Ca2+ movement into intact
wheat chloroplasts (Muto et al., 1982
) indicated that the
Ca2+ uptake occurs via an
H+/Ca2+-antiport mechanism,
and that the Km was only slightly higher than [Ca2+]cyt. Kreimer
et al. (1985a
, 1985b)
, who measured Ca2+ fluxes
across the envelope of intact chloroplasts isolated from spinach,
reported that Ca2+ transport into illuminated
chloroplasts could occur via electrogenic uniport and that this was
linked to photosynthetic electron transport.
The majority of the work done in this area has been carried out using
intact chloroplasts; however, that system has some disadvantages. For
example, it is difficult to monitor the nearly instantaneous influx or
efflux of ions, and therefore it is difficult to resolve the initial
rate kinetics of transport processes. In addition, the pH and ionic
composition of the stroma are not easy to control. Another drawback to
using intact chloroplasts is that it is difficult to examine the
directionality of transport processes, because it is difficult to
preload the chloroplasts with Ca2+ to measure
efflux.
An alternative approach, which we used in this study, involves the use
of membrane vesicles prepared from inner-envelope membranes isolated
from intact chloroplasts. Vesicles have been shown to be competent for
studying ion and metabolite movement across membranes (Sze, 1985
).
There are several advantages to using membrane vesicles over intact
organelles. For example, vesicles can be loaded with fluorescent
probes, allowing for the continuous fluorometric measurement of
substrate and ion transport. When used along with
stopped-flow spectrofluorometry, these processes can be monitored
almost instantaneously with measurement times of less than 2 ms, which
allows for the determination of initial rate kinetics of transport.
This method has been used to measure the symport movement of protons
with glycolate and D-glycerate (Young and McCarty, 1993
)
and the rapid proton-linked diffusion of nitrite as nitrous acid
(Shingles et al., 1996
) across the chloroplast inner-envelope membrane.
Another advantage of this method is that the pH and ionic content of
the intravesicular and external media can be easily manipulated, a procedure commonly used to study transport mechanisms. Finally, because
inner-envelope vesicles of either right-side-out or inside-out orientation can be prepared (Shingles and McCarty, 1995
), the directionality of transport processes can be characterized in detail.
Studies using liposomes loaded with the ratioable
Ca2+ fluorescent probe fura-2 have been performed
to measure Ca2+ transport catalyzed by
reconstituted annexin ion channels (Berendes et al., 1993
) and
ionophores such as ionomycin and A23187 (Blau and Weissmann, 1988
;
Fasolato and Pozzan, 1989
). In addition, fura-2 has been used to
monitor voltage-dependent Ca2+ movement across
the erythrocyte plasma membrane (Soldati et al., 1997
). Preliminary
experiments using chloroplast inner-envelope vesicles loaded with
Ca2+-sensitive fluorophores indicated that these
probes would be sensitive enough to detect small changes in
intravesicular free [Ca2+], and therefore could
be used to monitor Ca2+ movement across membranes
(Cleveland and McCarty, 1995
). In the present study this experimental
procedure was used to directly calculate the initial rates of
Ca2+ movement and to characterize further the
properties of Ca2+ transport across the
chloroplast inner envelope.
 |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
Reagents
Fura-2 was purchased from Molecular Probes (Eugene, OR). All other
reagents were of the highest grade commercially available. Stock
solutions of buffer components were passed through a column containing
Chelex-100 to reduce Ca2+ content before buffer
preparation.
Plant Material
Pea (Pisum sativum L. cv Laxton's Progress No. 9)
plants were grown from seed for 16 to 18 d in vermiculite in a
controlled-environment growth cabinet (Revco, Asheville, NC) set for
16-h day (24°C)/8-h night (20°C) periods. Spinach was obtained at
local markets.
Membrane Isolation
Intact chloroplasts were isolated according to the method of Joy
and Mills (1987)
. Inner envelopes were prepared as described by
Keegstra and Yousif (1986)
. Frozen, intact chloroplasts, equivalent to
between 80 and 120 mg of chlorophyll, were thawed at 4°C, refrozen at
20°C, and thawed again at 4°C. Chloroplast rupture was
facilitated by gentle homogenization using a pestle tissue grinder. The
homogenate was centrifuged at 3,150g for 15 min. The
resulting supernatants were collected and centrifuged at
27,000g for 90 min. Pellets were resuspended in 0.2 M Suc and placed on top of a 0.45/0.80/1.0 M
Suc step gradient and centrifuged at 105,000g for 18 h.
Inner-envelope membrane vesicles were recovered from the 0.80/1.0
M Suc interface. All of the operations described above were
performed at 4°C. Inner envelopes were stored under liquid nitrogen.
Vesicle Preparations
Suspensions of purified inner envelopes or asolectin (20 mg) were
diluted 4-fold in the appropriate resuspension buffer. The membranes
were pelleted by centrifugation at 144,000g for 1 h at
4°C and then resuspended in the same buffer before
vesicle-preparation protocols.
Membrane vesicles were also prepared using a hand-held, small-volume
extrusion apparatus (Shingles and McCarty, 1995
). Trace amounts of
Ca2+ in the filters and apparatus were removed by
passing through the apparatus a total of 5 mL of resuspension buffer
containing 10 mM K-Hepes, pH 8.0, 100 mM KCl,
100 mM Suc, and 100 µM EGTA. A total of 1.0 to 2.0 mL of a membrane suspension containing 1.2 mM fura-2
and about 1 mg of inner-envelope protein or 15 to 20 mg of asolectin
was then passed 9 to 11 times through the extrusion apparatus with a
polycarbonate filter (100-nm pore size) in place.
Inner-envelope vesicles, predominantly of the inside-out orientation,
were prepared by the freeze/thaw method described by Young and McCarty
(1993)
in a resuspension buffer containing 10 mM K-Hepes,
pH 8.0, 50 mM KCl, 50 mM choline chloride, 100 mM Suc, 100 µM EGTA, and 1.2 mM
fura-2.
All vesicle preparations were passed through a 1.6- × 10-cm Sephadex
G-50 column equilibrated with the appropriate resuspension buffer to
remove most of the external fura-2. To eliminate trace amounts of
external probe, the eluted vesicles were diluted 4-fold in resuspension
buffer and centrifuged at 144,000g for 20 min at 4°C. The
pellet comprising fura-2-loaded membrane vesicles was resuspended in
the same buffer and allowed to equilibrate for 1 to 2 h at 4°C.
Ca2+ Minielectrodes
The Ca2+ electrode was constructed as
described by Baudet et al. (1994)
. A 3-cm length of 1.67-mm (o.d.)
polyethylene tubing was dipped into a mixture of polyvinyl chloride and
potassium tetrakis chlorophenyl borate dissolved in tetrahydrofuran and the Ca2+ ionophore
N,N,N
,N
-tetracyclohexyl-3-oxapentanediamide
dissolved in 2-nitrophenyl octyl ether and allowed to dry overnight.
Dried electrodes were filled with 28.5 mM nitrilotriacetic
acid, pH 8.0, and 1.13 mM CaCl2 to
give approximately 1 µM free Ca2+
and an ionic strength of about 0.10 M. The electrodes were
allowed to equilibrate in this buffer for at least 3 d before use.
Fluorescence Measurements
Fura-2 fluorescence emission was monitored at 512 nm with
excitation at 340 nm (Fs) or 359 nm
(Fis) using a modified spectrofluorometer (model SLM-SPF-500C, Olis, Bogart, GA) and a stopped-flow apparatus (Olis). All slits were set at 10 nm with a cutoff filter (LP47, Oriel,
Stamford, CT) placed over the entrance to the emission monochromator.
Chamber A contained 2.0 mL of vesicle suspension, and chamber B
contained 2.0 mL of buffer of predetermined pH and composition so that
the intravesicular osmotic and ionic strengths were closely balanced
with those of the external medium. Chamber B also contained
CaCl2 when used. Mixing was achieved by a
nitrogen-driven piston at 80 p.s.i. All measurements were taken at
25°C.
Internal Buffering Capacity Measurements
To determine the
in of inner-envelope
vesicles known amounts of CaCl2 were added to the
vesicles in the stopped-flow apparatus and the resulting changes in
external pCa were monitored over time. The
in
relates the total number of moles of Ca2+ that
cross the vesicle membrane in a given number of vesicles and the
intravesicular pCa change that results under experimental conditions;
accordingly, it is expressed in nanomoles of Ca2+
per pCa unit per milligram of inner-envelope protein.
In this assay fura-2 was present as an indicator of the external pCa.
Spinach chloroplast inner-envelope vesicles were prepared via the
freeze/thaw procedure described previously with the following exceptions. The resuspension buffer consisted of 10 mM
K-Hepes, pH 8.0, 100 mM KCl, 100 mM Suc, and
100 µM EGTA. The intravesicular fura-2 was replaced by
1.2 mM
1,2-bis(o-aminophenoxy)ethane-N,N,N
,N
-tetraacetic acid to avoid interference with the fluorescence of the external fura-2. Finally, the EGTA concentration in the elution buffer used to
equilibrate the Sephadex G-50 column and to dilute the eluted vesicles
before centrifugation was reduced to 20 µM. However, the
concentrations of KCl, Suc, and K-Hepes, pH 8.0, in the elution buffer
were identical to those in the resuspension buffer.
Vesicle suspensions were diluted with an equal volume of elution buffer
supplemented with approximately 10 µM fura-2. The resulting mixture was loaded into chamber A of the stopped-flow apparatus. Chamber B contained buffer containing 100 mM
choline chloride plus 32 µM CaCl2.
The fluorescence of fura-2 was monitored for 2 min. The decrease in pCa
immediately after mixing was used to calculate the
out. This decrease was followed by a gradual increase in external pCa for the next 2 min as the external and internal [Ca2+] reached equilibrium. The final
overall extent of change in pCa allowed for the calculation of the
combination of
in and
out. From these data,
in was calculated.
Assays
The modified TCA-Lowry procedure of Bensadoun and Weinstein
(1976)
was used to determine the amount of protein in the
inner-envelope membrane vesicle preparations.
 |
RESULTS |
Calibration of Vesicles Loaded with Fura-2
The minielectrode used in this study was calibrated in a buffer
containing 12 mM EGTA, 15 mM nitrilotriacetic
acid, and 10 mM CaCl2. At the start
of the calibration process, the pH of the buffer was 4.0. Under these
conditions, almost all of the Ca2+ was
unchelated. The concentration of free Ca2+ in the
buffer was changed by varying the pH of the buffer from 4.0 to 9.0. This procedure allowed for the calibration of the minielectrode at
millimolar and submicromolar [Ca2+]. The
electrode gave a Nernstian response at both of these
[Ca2+] ranges (Fig.
1A). At each pH the pCa was calculated
using the MaxChelator program (Bers et al., 1994
).

View larger version (23K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
| Figure 1.
Ca2+ minielectrode calibration. The pH
of the calibration buffer containing 15 mM nitrilotriacetic
acid, 12 mM EGTA, and 10 mM CaCl2
was varied from 4.0 to 9.0, thereby decreasing the free
[Ca2+] (expressed as pCa) that was calculated using
computer software. At each pH the reading from the electrode was
recorded (A). Afterward, the excitation spectra of a suspension of
inner-envelope vesicles loaded with 1.2 mM fura-2 were
recorded in the presence of 1 µM ionomycin between 300 and 400 nm, with emission monitored at 512 nm after adding small
amounts of CaCl2 (B). The pCa of the vesicle suspension was
recorded using the minielectrode after each addition. The
Fs (340 nm) and
Fis (359 nm) data from each of the spectra
were used to produce the pCa versus
Fs/Fis
calibration curve (C).
|
|
When small amounts of CaCl2 were added to
membrane vesicles loaded with fura-2 in the presence of 1 µM ionomycin, thereby sequentially decreasing the
intravesicular pCa (i.e. increasing the internal
Ca2+ concentration), significant changes in the
excitation spectrum were observed (Fig. 1B). Although ionomycin
catalyzes Ca2+/H+ exchange,
the changes in the spectrum were not attributable to pH effects,
because fura-2 is insensitive to pH. The fluorescence change at 512 nm
brought on by CaCl2 addition was greatest at an
excitation wavelength of 340 nm, so this wavelength was used as the
Fs. However, with excitation at 359 nm, the
fluorescence was relatively insensitive to the change in
[Ca2+] inside the vesicles, so this
isoexcitation point was taken as the Fis.
After each addition of CaCl2, the fluorescence
values at Fs and
Fis were determined from excitation spectra
and the final pCa values were measured with the
Ca2+ minielectrode. The plot of
Fs/Fis versus
pCa produced the curve shown in Figure 1C.
According to Grynkiewicz et al. (1985)
, the fluorescence ratio of
fura-2 (R or
Fs/Fis) can be
related to [Ca2+] by the following equation:
|
(1)
|
The plot shown in Figure 1C yielded a curve that fit the
rearranged form of Equation 1:
|
(2)
|
where
(Fs/Fis)max
is the fluorescence ratio at a pCa value at which essentially all of
the fura-2 is bound to Ca2+, and
(Fs/Fis)min
is the ratio observed when all of the fura-2 is in the unchelated form.
From the plot of this particular curve, the pKd
was determined to be 7.0 and the
(Fs/Fis)min
and
(Fs/Fis)max were equal to 0.66 and 1.4, respectively. These values were observed to
vary only slightly among vesicle preparations; however, this calibration process was performed for each set of experiments. In each
preparation the relationship between Ca2+
chelation by fura-2 and pCa was approximately linear between pCa 6.5 and 7.5.
Determination of the Internal Buffering Capacity of
Inner-Envelope Vesicles
The internal buffering capacity of the inner-envelope vesicles
must be known to directly calculate the actual rate of
Ca2+ influx. The stopped-flow method used by
Young and McCarty (1993)
was used to determine buffering capacity by
mixing a known amount of CaCl2 with a vesicle
suspension. Fura-2 was present in the weakly buffered external medium
as an indicator of the external pCa. The observed decrease in pCa
immediately after mixing was used to calculate
out. This decrease was followed by a slow
increase in pCa (the rebound phase) over the next 2 min as the
extravesicular and intravesicular pCa reached equilibrium. The final
change in pCa allows for the calculation of the internal and external
buffering capacities.
In our experiments an average
in value of
7.0 ± 1.0 µM pCa unit
1 was
obtained. Because the concentration of inner-envelope protein in the
stopped-flow apparatus was 0.07 mg mL
1, the
internal buffering capacity was calculated to be 100 ± 14 nmol
Ca2+ pCa unit
1
mg
1 protein. The calculation of
in allows for the direct calculation of
the initial rate of Ca2+ movement as
the product of the initial rate in pCa units per second and the
internal buffering capacity.
Ca2+ Movement across Vesicle Membranes
To investigate the diffusive component of
Ca2+ influx, asolectin vesicles loaded with
fura-2 were mixed with CaCl2 and the fluorescence emission after excitation at 340 nm (Fs)
and 359 nm (Fis) was monitored over time.
Asolectin is a protein-free lipid mixture, so
Ca2+ would traverse these membranes via passive
diffusion. When these vesicles were mixed with approximately 0.35 µM free Ca2+, no decrease in
internal pCa was observed for the first 30 s (Fig.
2A). Even when the free
[Ca2+] was increased to 10 to 25 µM, no change in fura-2 fluorescence was observed (data
not shown), suggesting that the diffusive movement of
Ca2+ across nonproteinaceous membranes was quite
low. However, when 0.2 µM ionomycin was added to
the asolectin vesicles and subsequently mixed with a buffer containing
free Ca2+ at a concentration of 0.35 µM, a rapid Ca2+ influx at a rate
of 1.0 pCa unit s
1 was observed (Fig. 2A),
confirming that fura-2 was indeed present inside these vesicles and was
still sensitive to changes in intravesicular pCa.

View larger version (25K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
| Figure 2.
Ca2+ influx in asolectin and
chloroplast inner-envelope vesicles. A, Asolectin vesicles at pH 8.0 were mixed with pH 8.0 buffer containing CaCl2 such that
the free external [Ca2+] after mixing was 0.35 µM. When used, the asolectin vesicles were preincubated
with 0.2 µM ionomycin for 15 min. B, Inner-envelope
vesicles (50 µg of protein) prepared by extrusion were mixed under
the same conditions as in A with 1.0 µM free
Ca2+. C, Inner-envelope vesicles (50 µg of
protein) prepared by the freeze/thaw method were mixed with 1.0 µM free Ca2+. Data were fit to the single
exponential equation using the graphing program Kaleidagraph (Synergy
Software, Reading, PA).
|
|
Membranes that were extruded were shown to be predominantly
right-side-out, whereas membranes subjected to a freeze/thaw treatment were largely inside-out in orientation (Shingles and McCarty, 1995
).
The addition of 1.0 µM free Ca2+ to
inner-envelope membrane vesicles prepared by extrusion resulted in a
decrease in intravesicular pCa during the first 30 s (Fig. 2B).
The initial rate of Ca2+ transport under these
conditions was equal to 0.06 pCa unit s
1.
However, when inner-envelope membrane vesicles prepared by the freeze/thaw method were used (Fig. 2C), the observed initial rate of
Ca2+ influx was approximately 0.03 pCa unit
s
1. When vesicles of either orientation were
mixed with Ca2+ in the presence of 0.2 µM ionomycin, the added Ca2+
equilibrated within the 1st s (data not shown).
Effect of a Proton Gradient on Ca2+ Influx into
Inner-Envelope Vesicles
To investigate the possibility that a proton gradient may
stimulate Ca2+ uptake, Ca2+
influx into inner-envelope vesicles prepared by extrusion was monitored
in the stopped-flow apparatus under several conditions. In these assays
the free external [Ca2+] was equal to 0.4 µM. When the external and internal pH were equivalent,
the initial rate of Ca2+ transport was determined
to be 1.1 pCa units mg
1 protein
s
1 (Fig. 3).
However, when the vesicles in pH 8.0 buffer (containing 100 mM KCl) were mixed with the same buffer, giving a final
external pH of 7.0 in the presence of Ca2+, the
initial rate increased to approximately 2.3 pCa units
mg
1 protein s
1 (Fig.
3). This observation may be consistent with a
Ca2+/H+-symport mechanism
for Ca2+ movement across inner-envelope vesicles,
or it may reflect the dependence of Ca2+ uptake
on pH. Because the proton gradient has a 
component, the results
are also consistent with the potential-stimulated uniport mechanism
described by Kreimer et al. (1985b)
. A pH difference of 1.0 unit
corresponds to a 
of
59 mV (lumen negative) at 25°C. In the
presence of 2 nM valinomycin, which dissipates the potential gradient while essentially leaving the magnitude of the pH
gradient unaffected, the stimulation of Ca2+
movement by the pH increase disappeared (Fig. 3). Finally, when the
vesicles were mixed with pH 8.0 buffer containing 100 mM
choline chloride in the presence of valinomycin, resulting in the
formation of a 
of about
16 mV, the initial rate of
Ca2+ uptake was equivalent to that produced in
the pH-increase experiment (Fig. 3). Therefore, it appears that
membrane potential, rather than external pH or the pH gradient, is the
cause of the stimulation of Ca2+ uptake by a pH
increase.

View larger version (22K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
| Figure 3.
pH and potential gradient effects on
Ca2+ transport across inner-envelope vesicles. Extruded
inner-envelope vesicles (15 µg of protein) at pH 8.0 were mixed with
various buffers containing Ca2+ such that after mixing the
free external [Ca2+] was approximately 0.4 µM. When the external pH was 7.0 in the absence of
valinomycin, the  was calculated to be 59 mV using the Nernst
equation. When used, 2 nM valinomycin was preincubated with
vesicles for 30 min on ice. A membrane potential of about 16 mV was
imposed across the vesicle membranes by mixing vesicles in 100 mM KCl, 10 mM K-Hepes, 100 mM Suc,
and 100 µM EGTA with an equal volume of the same buffer
in which the 100 mM KCl was replaced with 100 mM choline chloride. The instantaneous equilibration of
K+ in the presence of valinomycin resulted in a negatively
charged vesicle interior.
|
|
The Effect of the Membrane Potential on Ca2+ Influx
It is interesting to note that a 
of
59 mV resulted
in the same Ca2+ uptake rate as a

of
16 mV (Fig. 3). To further investigate the effect of 
on Ca2+ uptake, Ca2+
influx was measured as the magnitude of 
was varied and the external free [Ca2+] was kept constant at 0.65 µM. As illustrated in Figure
4, a significant increase in the initial
rate was observed as the magnitude of the membrane potential was
increased from 0 to
15.8 mV (lumen negative). Furthermore, the
stimulation of Ca2+ uptake by 
appears to
be nearly saturated at the highest 
used.

View larger version (17K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
| Figure 4.
Potential gradient effect on Ca2+
transport across inner-envelope vesicles. Ca2+ influx into
inner-envelope vesicles prepared by extrusion was monitored under
varying magnitudes of  generated by adjusting the KCl and choline
chloride solutions used in Figure 3. The intravesicular
[K+] was maintained at 110 mM. The  was
varied by changing the external [K+]. Inner-envelope
vesicles (15 µg of protein) were incubated with 2 nM
valinomycin for 30 min before each experiment.
|
|
Ca2+ Concentration Dependence of Initial Rates of
Ca2+ Movement
To determine the relationship between the initial rate of
Ca2+ influx and external free
[Ca2+], inner-envelope vesicles were mixed with
buffers so that the 
was maintained at approximately
16 mV
while free [Ca2+] was varied in the
submicromolar range. As seen in Figure 5, the observed increase in initial rate with respect to increasing free
[Ca2+] was linear over the range studied. Also,
because the initial internal pCa in the majority of the vesicle
preparations ranged from 7.2 to 7.3 units, it follows that the initial
rate of Ca2+ influx would be minimal when the
external [Ca2+] was equal to 0.06 µM (Fig. 5), which corresponds to an external pCa of 7.22 units. Both Muto et al. (1982)
and Kreimer et al. (1985b)
used
Ca2+ concentrations in their studies that
exceeded the estimated physiological concentration of 0.05 to 0.4 µM in the plant cell cytosol (Evans et al., 1991
). In
fact, the Km for Ca2+
uptake by isolated chloroplasts was determined to be 188 µM (Kreimer et al., 1985b
), which indicates that
Ca2+ transport would not be saturable at low
physiological levels, as seen in Figure 5. A limitation of these
experiments is that Ca2+ concentrations higher
than about 1 µM cannot be measured reliably, because
fura-2 fluorescence becomes saturated when the intravesicular [Ca2+] exceeds this value.

View larger version (18K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
| Figure 5.
Effect of [Ca2+] on transport across
inner-envelope vesicles. Extruded inner-envelope vesicles (15 µg of
protein) were mixed with buffer containing various concentrations of
free Ca2+, and Ca2+ influx was monitored. In
each experiment a membrane potential of approximately 16 mV was
imposed across the vesicle membranes, as described in Figure 3.
|
|
Effect of Inhibitors on Ca2+ Influx
In a previous study (Kreimer et al., 1985a
, 1985b
)
Ca2+ influx into intact chloroplasts was shown to
be inhibited by micromolar amounts of ruthenium red. Similar results
were observed in this study. When 0.4 µM
Ca2+ was present in the external medium and

was
16 mV (lumen negative), the initial rate of
Ca2+ influx was equal to 2.8 pCa units
mg
1 protein s
1. In the
presence of 10 µM ruthenium red, the observed
Ca2+-transport activity was 0.1 pCa unit
mg
1 protein s
1, an
inhibition of 96% (Table I).
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Table I.
Effect of inhibitors on Ca2+ influx into
pea chloroplast inner-envelope membranes prepared by extrusion
Ca2+ movement was monitored for 30 s in the absence
and presence of known Ca2+-channel blockers at a
concentration of 10 µM. In each experiment a membrane
potential of 16 mV (when used) was imposed across the vesicle
membranes and the [Ca2+] in the external medium was equal
to 0.4 µM. The amount of inner-envelope protein in each
experiment was approximately 15 µg.
|
|
Other pharmacological agents known to block
Ca2+-channel activity were also tested for their
effects on Ca2+ movement. Diltiazem inhibited the
non-potential-dependent Ca2+ influx by
approximately 85%, but only inhibited potential-stimulated Ca2+ influx by 25% (Table I).
LaCl3 and two other known
Ca2+-channel blockers, nifedipine and verapamil,
had little inhibitory effect on Ca2+ transport.
Other divalent cations that might compete for
Ca2+ uptake were not tested because of their
known effects on fura-2 fluorescence. However, an independent study on
divalent cation uptake could be performed using fura-2-loaded membrane
vesicles.
 |
DISCUSSION |
In this study we have demonstrated that a sensitive
Ca2+ probe, fura-2, can be loaded into
chloroplast inner-envelope vesicles and used to monitor
Ca2+ transport across this membrane. This system
has several advantages, including control of the buffer components on
both sides of the membrane, the analysis of Ca2+
movement under essentially zero trans conditions, and
sensitivity to Ca2+ at submicromolar levels.
Combined with stopped-flow spectrofluorometry, the movement of
Ca2+ can be followed with a resolution time of 2 ms (Fig. 2). In addition, previous methods used to produce membrane
vesicles of right-side-out or inside-out orientation (Shingles and
McCarty, 1995
) allow for the evaluation of the sidedness of
Ca2+ movement.
Previous studies using intact chloroplasts have demonstrated
light-stimulated Ca2+ uptake (Muto et al., 1982
;
Kreimer et al., 1985b
). The mechanism by which
Ca2+ influx occurs in chloroplasts is in dispute.
Muto et al. (1982)
claimed the presence of a
Ca2+/H+ antiporter, whereas
Kreimer et al. (1985b)
concluded that this process was mediated by an
electrogenic uniport-carrier system. In our inner-envelope vesicle
preparations we were not able to measure any
Ca2+-linked, proton transport using membrane
vesicles loaded with the pH-sensitive fluorophore pyranine (data not
shown). This would seem to indicate that Ca2+
does not move across these membrane vesicles by a
Ca2+/H+-antiport mechanism.
Huang et al. (1993)
reported that an antibody raised against a portion
of a putative Ca2+-ATPase recognizes a 95-kD
polypeptide in chloroplast inner-envelope preparations, suggesting that
Ca2+ pumping might also be a mechanism for moving
Ca2+ across this membrane. However, they were not
able to show any Ca2+-dependent ATPase activity
or ATP-dependent Ca2+ uptake in their
inner-envelope preparations from pea chloroplasts. Similarly, we were
not able to measure either of these activities using fura-2-loaded
vesicles or a 45Ca assay in the presence or
absence of added calmodulin (data not shown).
Because the rate at which Ca2+ diffuses across
nonproteinaceous membranes is very low (Fig. 2A), the movement of
Ca2+ across the chloroplast inner-envelope
membrane observed in this study indicates the presence of a
Ca2+ uniporter in our vesicle preparations. The
influx of Ca2+ into predominantly right-side-out
inner-envelope vesicles was stimulated by a negative 
and was
very sensitive to micromolar amounts of ruthenium red (Table I). These
results are in agreement with those of previous studies using intact
chloroplasts (Kreimer et al., 1985a
, 1985b
). Furthermore, a high
magnitude of 
may not be necessary to fully stimulate
Ca2+-transport activity (Fig. 4). The observation
that Ca2+ influx does not increase at voltages
more negative than
11.8 mV indicates that uptake is not dependent on
an electrophoretic driving force, but, rather, may occur through a
voltage-dependent channel. In addition, the fact that
Ca2+ influx does increase with
Ca2+ concentration at a constant 
of
16
mV (Fig. 5) indicates that this channel would be
Ca2+ specific.
The initial rate of Ca2+ influx at a free
Ca2+ concentration of 0.2 to 0.4 µM
was determined to range between 1.0 and 3.0 pCa units
mg
1 protein s
1 (Fig.
5). Under these conditions the
in of the
vesicles was equal to approximately 100 nmol Ca2+
pCa unit
1 mg
1
inner-envelope protein. Assuming that there is 0.1 mg of inner-envelope protein per mg of chlorophyll (Young and McCarty, 1993
), the initial rate was calculated to range from 0.54 to 1.62 µmol
Ca2+ h
1
mg
1 chlorophyll at 25°C. These rates are
10-fold lower than the rates calculated by Kreimer et al. (1985b)
;
however, we used a [Ca2+] of up to 100 times
lower than that used in the previous study.
Antagonists to Ca2+ channels have been frequently
used to characterize transport processes. Various drugs such as
verapamil, nifedipine, and diltiazem have been frequently used as
inhibitors of voltage-dependent Ca2+ channels
(Triggle, 1990
; Takahashi et al., 1997
). In this study Ca2+ influx under nonpotential conditions was
greatly inhibited by diltiazem and ruthenium red (Table I). The weak
inhibition by diltiazem under potential gradient conditions suggests
that there may be more than one pathway for Ca2+
uptake across chloroplast inner envelopes. Furthermore,
LaCl3 can be used to inhibit a
ruthenium-red-insensitive
Ca2+/H+ exchanger in liver
and kidney mitochondria (Saris and Allshire, 1989
). In chloroplast
inner-envelope membranes LaCl3 had no effect, indicating that Ca2+ does not move by a
Ca2+/H+ antiporter. In
contrast, ruthenium red, which inhibits the plant mitochondrial
Ca2+ uniporter (Wilson and Graesser, 1976
),
almost completely inhibited Ca2+ movement across
chloroplast inner-envelope vesicles (Table I).
Chloroplasts have been reported to contain from 4 to 23 mM
total Ca2+ (Portis and Heldt, 1976
). The
concentration of free Ca2+ in the stroma of
chloroplasts kept in the dark was determined to be 2.4 to 6.3 µM (Kreimer et al., 1988
), which indicates that most of
the Ca2+ is sequestered at binding sites within
the chloroplast. Johnson et al. (1995)
, using a transgenic tobacco line
in which expressed apoaequorin was targeted to the chloroplast stroma,
estimated that under light conditions, chloroplasts maintain basal free [Ca2+] in the low nanomolar range (150 nM), indicating that even more Ca2+-binding sites, such as those on PSII (Grove
and Brudvig, 1998
), become available during illumination. However, when
plants are transferred from light to dark conditions, a transient
increase in free stromal [Ca2+], which peaks at
5 to 10 µM, takes place (Johnson et al., 1995
). The
transient nature of the stromal [Ca2+] increase
as plants are switched from light to dark suggests that there may be a
mechanism for Ca2+ efflux across the inner
envelope, and also indicates that Ca2+ efflux may
be slower than influx. Under certain conditions, Kreimer et al. (1985a
,
1985b)
observed an efflux rather than a net influx of
Ca2+ into intact chloroplasts; however, they were
unable to conclude whether efflux occurred via a reversal of uniport.
Inner-envelope membranes prepared by the freeze/thaw method produce
vesicles of predominantly inside-out orientation (Shingles and McCarty,
1995
). When vesicles in pH 8.0 buffer prepared by the freeze/thaw
method were mixed with 1 µM free
Ca2+, a significant Ca2+
influx was observed (Fig. 2C). This movement was also inhibited by
ruthenium red but not as strongly as in predominantly right-side-out vesicles (data not shown). Therefore, it is possible that the Ca2+ uniporter may be reversed and may catalyze
the net efflux of Ca2+ after chloroplasts are
transferred from light to dark conditions. However, because the initial
rates measured with predominantly inside-out vesicles were one-third of
those measured with predominantly right-side-out vesicles, there is a
directional preference to Ca2+ transport across
the chloroplast inner envelope favoring Ca2+
uptake.
In this study the initial rate of Ca2+ uniport
activity across the pea chloroplast inner envelope under physiological
free [Ca2+] was measured to be 0.5 to 1.6 µmol h
1 mg
1
chlorophyll and was demonstrated to be stimulated by a negative membrane potential. It has been demonstrated that an inwardly directed
pH gradient of 0.25 to 0.5 unit can be maintained across the
chloroplast envelope by the H+-ATPase present in
the inner-envelope membrane (Shingles and McCarty, 1994
). This
H+ gradient also represents a 
of 15 to 30 mV, enough to couple this ATPase to the potential-stimulated
Ca2+ uniporter. This mechanism could result in
the efficient uptake of Ca2+ by the chloroplasts
as well as the activation of photosynthetic CO2
assimilation.
 |
FOOTNOTES |
1
This work was supported by the U.S. Department
of Energy (grant no. DE-FG02-92ER 200 280).
*
Corresponding author; e-mail rem1{at}jhu.edu; fax 1-410-516-5213.
Received June 30, 1998;
accepted September 18, 1998.
 |
ABBREVIATIONS |
Abbreviations:
in, internal
Ca2+-buffering capacity.
out, external
Ca2+-buffering capacity.
[Ca2+]cyt, free [Ca2+] in the
cytosol.

, membrane potential difference.
Fs, fluorescence at a Ca-sensitive
wavelength.
Fis, fluorescence at a
Ca-insensitive wavelength.
 |
ACKNOWLEDGMENT |
We thank Leonard Beaton for cultivating the pea plants and
preparing the chloroplasts.
 |
LITERATURE CITED |
Baudet S,
Hove-Madsen L,
Bers DM
(1994)
How to make and use Ca2+-specific mini- and microelectrodes.
Methods Cell Biol
40:
93-113
[Web of Science][Medline]
Bensadoun A,
Weinstein D
(1976)
Assay of proteins in the presence of interfering materials.
Anal Biochem
70:
241-250
[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline]
Berendes R,
Burger A,
Voges D,
Demange P,
Huber R
(1993)
Calcium influx through annexin V ion channels into large unilamellar vesicles measured with fura-2.
FEBS Lett
317:
131-134
[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline]
Bers DM,
Patton CW,
Nuccitelli R
(1994)
A practical guide to the preparation of Ca2+ buffers.
Methods Cell Biol
40:
3-29
[Web of Science][Medline]
Blau L,
Weissmann G
(1988)
Transmembrane Ca2+ movements mediated by ionomycin and phosphatidate in liposomes with fura 2 entrapped.
Biochemistry
27:
5661-5666
[CrossRef][Medline]
Brand JJ,
Becker DW
(1984)
Evidence for direct roles of Ca2+ in photosynthesis.
J Bioenerg Biomembr
16:
239-249
[Medline]
Cleveland MJ,
McCarty RE
(1995)
Calcium influx in chloroplast inner envelope vesicles loaded with the fluorescent probe mag-indo-1 (abstract no. 391).
Plant Physiol
108:
S-84
Evans DE,
Briars SA,
Williams LE
(1991)
Active Ca2+ transport by plant cell membranes.
J Exp Bot
42:
285-303
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
Fasolato C,
Pozzan T
(1989)
Effect of membrane potential on divalent cation transport catalyzed by the "electroneutral" ionophores A23187 and ionomycin.
J Biol Chem
264:
19630-19636
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
Grove GN,
Brudvig GW
(1998)
Calcium binding studies on photosystem II using a Ca2+-selective electrode.
Biochemistry
37:
1532-1539
[CrossRef][Medline]
Grynkiewicz G,
Poenie M,
Tsien RY
(1985)
A new generation of Ca2+ indicators with greatly improved fluorescence properties.
J Biol Chem
260:
3440-3450
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
Huang L,
Berkelman T,
Franklin AE,
Hoffman NE
(1993)
Characterization of a gene encoding a Ca2+-ATPase-like protein in the plastid envelope.
Proc Natl Acad Sci USA
90:
10066-10070
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
Johnson CH,
Knight MR,
Kondo T,
Masson P,
Sedbrook J,
Haley A,
Trewavas A
(1995)
Circadian oscillations of cytosolic and chloroplastic free Ca2+ in plants.
Science
269:
1863-1865
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
Joy KW,
Mills WR
(1987)
Purification of chloroplasts using silica solutions.
Methods Enzymol
148:
179-188
Keegstra K,
Yousif AE
(1986)
Isolation and characterization of chloroplast envelope membranes.
Methods Enzymol
118:
316-325
[Web of Science]
Kreimer G,
Melkonian M,
Holtum JAM,
Latzko E
(1985a)
Characterization of Ca2+ fluxes across the envelope of intact spinach chloroplasts.
Planta
166:
515-523
[CrossRef]
Kreimer G,
Melkonian M,
Holtum JAM,
Latzko E
(1988)
Stromal free Ca2+ concentration and light-mediated activation of chloroplast fructose-1,6-bisphosphatase.
Plant Physiol
86:
423-428
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
Kreimer G,
Melkonian M,
Latzko E
(1985b)
An electrogenic uniport mediates light-dependent Ca2+ influx into intact spinach chloroplasts.
FEBS Lett
180:
253-258
[CrossRef]
Muto S,
Izawa S,
Miyachi S
(1982)
Light-induced Ca2+ uptake by intact chloroplasts.
FEBS Lett
139:
250-254
[CrossRef]
Pineros M,
Tester M
(1997)
Calcium channels in higher plant cells: selectivity, regulation and pharmacology.
J Exp Bot
48:
551-577
Portis AR Jr,
Heldt HW
(1976)
Light-dependent changes of the Mg2+ concentration in the stroma in relation to the Mg2+ dependency of CO2 fixation in intact chloroplasts.
Biochim Biophys Acta
449:
434-446
[Medline]
Saris NL,
Allshire A
(1989)
Calcium ion transport in mitochondria.
Methods Enzymol
174:
68-85
[Medline]
Shingles R,
McCarty RE
(1994)
Direct measurement of ATP-dependent proton concentration changes and characterization of a K+-stimulated ATPase in pea chloroplast inner envelope vesicles.
Plant Physiol
106:
731-737
[Abstract]
Shingles R,
McCarty RE
(1995)
Production of membrane vesicles by extrusion: size distribution, enzyme activity, and orientation of plasma membrane and chloroplast inner-envelope membrane vesicles.
Anal Biochem
229:
92-98
[CrossRef][Medline]
Shingles R,
Roh MH,
McCarty RE
(1996)
Nitrite transport in chloroplast inner envelope vesicles. I. Direct measurement of proton-linked transport.
Plant Physiol
112:
1375-1381
[Abstract]
Soldati L,
Spaventa R,
Vezzoli G,
Zerbi S,
Adamo D,
Caumo A,
Rivera R,
Bianchi G
(1997)
Characterization of voltage-dependent Ca2+ influx in human erythrocytes by fura-2.
Biochem Biophys Res Commun
236:
549-554
[CrossRef][Medline]
Sze H
(1985)
H+-translocating ATPases: advances using membrane vesicles.
Annu Rev Plant Physiol
36:
175-208
[CrossRef][Web of Science]
Takahashi K,
Isobe M,
Knight MR,
Trewavas AJ,
Muto S
(1997)
Hypoosmotic shock induces increases in cytosolic Ca2+ in tobacco suspension-cultured cells.
Plant Physiol
113:
587-594
[Abstract]
Triggle DJ
(1990)
Calcium, Ca2+ channels, and Ca2+ channel antagonists.
Can J Physiol Pharmacol
68:
1474-1481
[Web of Science][Medline]
Wilson RH,
Graesser RJ
(1976)
Ion transport in plant mitochondria.
In
A Pirson,
MH Zimmermann,
eds, Encyclopedia of Plant Physiology, Ed 1, Vol 3.
Springer-Verlag, Berlin, pp 377-397
Young XK,
McCarty RE
(1993)
Assay of proton-coupled glycolate and D-glycerate transport into chloroplast inner envelope membrane vesicles by stopped-flow fluorescence.
Plant Physiol
101:
793-799
[Abstract]