|
|
||||||||
|
Plant Physiol, November 2001, Vol. 127, pp. 973-985
Insights into the Functional Architecture of the Catalytic Center
of a Maize
|
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The maize (Zea mays)
-glucosidase Zm-p60.1 has
been implicated in regulation of plant development by the targeted
release of free cytokinins from cytokinin-O-glucosides,
their inactive storage forms. The crystal structure of the wild-type
enzyme was solved at 2.05-Å resolution, allowing molecular docking
analysis to be conducted. This indicated that the enzyme specificity
toward substrates with aryl aglycones is determined by aglycone
aromatic system stacking with W373, and interactions with edges of
F193, F200, and F461 located opposite W373 in a slot-like
aglycone-binding site. These aglycone-active site interactions recently
were hypothesized to determine substrate specificity in inactive enzyme
substrate complexes of ZM-Glu1, an allozyme of Zm-p60.1. Here, we test
this hypothesis by kinetic analysis of F193I/Y/W mutants. The decreased Km of all mutants confirmed the involvement
of F193 in determining enzyme affinity toward substrates with an
aromatic aglycone. It was unexpected that a 30-fold decrease in
kcat was found in F193I mutant compared with
the wild type. Kinetic analysis and computer modeling demonstrated that
the F193-aglycone-W373 interaction not only contributes to aglycone
recognition as hypothesized previously but also codetermines catalytic
rate by fixing the glucosidic bond in an orientation favorable for
attack by the catalytic pair, E186 and E401. The catalytic pair,
assigned initially by their location in the structure, was confirmed by
kinetic analysis of E186D/Q and E401D/Q mutants. It was unexpected that
the E401D as well as C205S and C211S mutations dramatically impaired
the assembly of a catalysis-competent homodimer, suggesting novel links
between the active site structure and dimer formation.
| |
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-Glucosidases (
-glucoside
glucohydrolases, EC 3.2.1.21) are a widespread group of enzymes
hydrolyzing a broad variety of aryl- and
alkyl-
-D-glucosides as well as glucosides with only a
carbohydrate moiety. Interest in
-glucosidase research reflects essential functions of
-glucosidases in a variety of basic
biological processes ranging from developmental regulation to chemical
defense against pathogen attack, and in a number of industrial
applications such as biomass conversion. In plants,
-glucosidases
have been implicated in regulating various aspects of development, e.g. phytohormone activation (Smith and van Staden, 1978
; Brzobohatý et al., 1994
), cell wall degradation in the endosperm during
germination (Leah et al., 1995
), and pathogen defense reactions
(Poulton, 1990
).
Plant
-glucosidases are classified as family 1 of retaining glycosyl
hydrolases according to their primary structure (Henrissat and Bairoch,
1993
; Henrissat et al., 1995
). Hydrolysis of a glycosidic bond involves
two essential carboxylates, one acting as a general acid/base catalyst
and the other as a nucleophile (Sinnott, 1990
). The hydrolysis is
initiated by the nucleophilic attack at the anomeric carbon (C1) of the
substrate that results in the formation of glycosyl enzyme intermediate
followed by the release of the aglycone facilitated by protonation of
the glycosidic oxygen by the acid catalyst (the glycosylation step).
The deprotonated acid catalyst acting now as a base (anion) removes a
proton from water, and the resulting hydroxyl anion attacks the
covalent bond of the glycosyl enzyme intermediate. As a result of the
attack, Glc is released and nucleophile regenerated (the
deglycosylation step). For example, in the homodimeric
Agrobacterium faecalis
-glucosidase (further referred to
as A. faecalis
-glucosidase) E358 was identified as
the nucleophile by means of mechanism-based inactivators and site-directed mutagenesis (Withers et al., 1990
; Withers et al., 1992
).
E170 subsequently was demonstrated to serve as the general acid/base
catalyst based on chemical rescue of inactive mutants in A. faecalis
-glucosidase (Wang et al., 1995
). E358 and E170 are
conserved in all members of family 1 of glycosyl hydrolases, and reside
in the ITENG and TXNEX motifs (where X is a hydrophobic amino acid
residue), respectively.
Three-dimensional structures of family 1
-gly-cosidases from six
divergent species have been solved recently (Barrett et al., 1995
;
Wiesmann et al., 1995
; Aguilar et al., 1997
; Burmeister et al., 1997
;
Sanz-Aparicio et al., 1998
; Chi et al., 1999
). Although levels of
sequence identity vary between 17% and 44% in the
-glycosidases, their structures have proved to be highly similar. The overall fold in
the enzymes is a single domain (
/
)8 barrel
as predicted for family 1 glycosyl hydrolases. Glu residues residing in
the conserved TXNEX and ITENG motifs are located at the C termini of
strands 4 and 7, respectively, and are separated by approximately 5.5 Å, a feature typical for retaining glycosyl hydrolases. This is
consistent with the classification of these
-glycosidases into the
4/7 superfamily (Henrissat et al., 1995
; Jenkins et al., 1995
). In
myrosinases (
-thioglucosidases), the position of E acting as the
acid/base catalyst is occupied by Q. In myrosinase substrates,
glucosinolates, the aglycone is an excellent leaving group; thus, there
is no need to provide protonation assistance for aglycone departure as
reported for Sinapis alba myrosinase (SAMyr; Burmeister et
al., 1997
).
Thus, substantial progress has been achieved in understanding the
mechanism of glucosidic bond cleavage and elucidating the roles of the
two catalytic Glu residues within the active site that are involved in
catalysis (the catalytic pair). However, until very recently, no
experimental data on molecular determination of aglycone specificity in
-glucosidases were available. Yet, given the tremendous diversity of
aglycone moieties in natural glucosides that reflects their varied
biological functions, fine tuning of diverse biological processes in
plants relies to a great extent on well-defined specificity in a number
of
-glucosidases toward their respective aglycones. Elucidation of
aglycone specificity in
-glucosidases is a key prerequisite toward
uncovering their precise role(s) in biological processes that involve
glucosylation and deglucosylation as regulatory elements. At the same
time, the ability to modulate specificity in
-glucosidases holds
considerable promise in terms of their biotechnological applications.
In maize (Zea mays), a
-glucosidase preferentially
hydrolyzing cytokinin-O- and N3-glucosides in vitro and in
vivo was identified, and a corresponding cDNA, Zm-p60.1, was
cloned (Campos et al., 1992
; Brzobohatý et al., 1993
). Based on
its enzyme activity and highly specific expression pattern, Zm-p60.1
has been suggested to be one of the key enzymes involved in the
regulation of plant development by releasing active phytohomornes,
cytokinins, from cytokinin-O-glucosides, their inactive
storage and transport forms (Brzobohatý et al., 1993
;
Kristoffersen et al., 2000
). Further characterization revealed that
Zm-p60.1 dimer formation is an essential prerequisite for obtaining
enzyme activity (Rotrekl et al., 1999
). The enzyme has been localized
to plastids/chloroplasts (Kristoffersen et al., 2000
). As a first step
toward addressing the mechanism of catalytic activity and substrate
specificity the enzyme was purified, crystallized, and the crystals
were subjected to preliminary x-ray analysis (Vévodová et
al., 2001
).
A cDNA containing an identical open reading frame has been cloned
independently and sequenced by Esen and Shahid (1995;
direct submission). Using this cDNA, ZM-Glu1, an allozyme
of Zm-p60.1 processed five residues upstream of the N terminus
identified in mature Zm-p60.1 (Brzobohatý et al., 1993
), was
produced in Escherichia coli. Substrate specificity analysis
revealed that, apart from artificial chromogenic and fluorogenic
glucosides designed specifically to monitor general
-glucosidase activity, ZM- Glu1 could hydrolyze
4-dihydroxy-7-methoxy-1,4-benzoxazin-3-one (DIMBOA)-glucoside (DIMBOA- Glc; Cicek and Esen, 1999
) in a manner
similar to a
-glucosidase purified from maize seedlings (Babcock and
Esen, 1994
). Based on this finding, it has been suggested that ZM-Glu1
is involved in defense against pathogens by releasing the toxic
aglycone (DIMBOA) from its storage form, DIMBOA-Glc. However, no direct
experimental evidence confirming that ZM-Glu1 is actually involved in
defense response in planta has been published. Crystal structure of the wild-type (WT) ZM-Glu1 at 2.5-Å resolution, and that of a complex of
ZM-Glu1 with the non-hydrolyzable inhibitor p-nitrophenyl
-D-thioglucopyranoside, were solved recently (Czjzek et
al., 2001
). The cocrystal structure of an inactive mutant of ZM-Glu1
and DIMBOA-Glc complex subsequently was solved at 2.1-Å
resolution. The data permitted visualization of the aglycone within
ZM-Glu1 active site. The aglycone is sandwiched between W378 on one
side and F198, F205, and F466 (equivalent to positions W373, F193,
F200, and F461 in the sequence of Zm-p60.1) on the other side of the
active center. The structure prompted the hypothesis that the specific
conformation of these four hydrophobic amino acids and the shape of the
aglycone-binding site they form determine aglycone recognition and
substrate specificity in ZM-Glu1 (Czjzek et al., 2000
).
The work presented now provides a test of this hypothesis via a kinetic analysis of mutants at several active site residues, including F193 in the aglycone-binding pocket. An improved crystallographic structure at 2.05-Å resolution allowed computer modeling of the structural consequences of the F193 mutations. Together, these analyses confirm that F193 is involved in determining the affinity of Zm-p60.1 toward aromatic aglycones as reflected in reduced Km values in the mutants, but, unexpectedly, they clearly demonstrate a further role of F193 in determining the rate of glycosidic bond hydrolysis. Furthermore, a kinetic analysis of E186D/Q and E401D/Q confirmed that E186 and E401 constitute the catalytic pair, and, surprisingly, that the E401D mutation hinders the assembly of enzymatically active dimers suggesting a previously unrecognized link between the active site architecture and dimer interface.
| |
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Structure of the Zm-p60.1
-Glucosidase
The crystal structure of the Zm-p60.1
-glucosidase was solved
by molecular replacement at 2.05-Å resolution. Concomitantly with
solving the Zm-p60.1 structure, structures of ZM-Glu1, an allozyme of
Zm-p60.1, and ZM-Glu1 inactive mutant substrate complex have been
published by an independent group (Czjzek et al., 2000
, 2001
). The
Zm-p60.1 structure presented here is more appropriate for molecular
docking and computer modeling because the ZM-Glu1 structure was solved
at lower resolution (2.5 Å). The inactive mutant substrate structure
was solved at a resolution (2.1 Å) comparable with our structure.
However, employment of the complex structure for substrate docking is
not optimal because the structure must be different to that one found
in the wild type to prevent a sterical clash between the mutated amino
acid residue and the ligand. Otherwise, the structures of the wild-type
enzymes are, within an experimental error, identical. To prevent
unnecessary duplications, here, we restrict description of the
structure of the protein to presentation of basic overall features of
Zm-p60.1 structure, and we focus mainly on those that are essential for interpretation of our functional analysis of the catalytic center.
The protein is a homodimer in solution and it crystallized as a homodimer in one asymmetric unit as well. However, due to the different packing environments, there are some differences between these two monomers. For example, clear electron density from residue A6 to A495 can be seen in monomer A, whereas B11 to B502 was shown for monomer B. Some of the residues from solvent-accessible areas (mainly Arg, Lys, glutamic, and aspartic acids) are disordered and have been refined with the partial occupancies. Crystallographic results are summarized in Table I.
|
Zm-p60.1 monomer is comprised of a single
(
/
)8 barrel domain (Figs.
1 and 2).
Structure analysis confirmed that C205 and C211 form a disulfide bridge
that has been identified previously (Rotrekl et al., 1999
; Fig.
2).
|
|
Zm-p60.1 monomers do not possess any detectable catalytic activity
(Rotrekl et al., 1999
), and no experimental evidence on the mechanism
by which homodimer assembly contributes to formation of
catalysis-competent state of the enzyme is available yet. Description of the dimerisation interface is the first step toward understanding the role of homodimer formation in the assembly of a
catalysis-competent structure in Zm-p60.1 and related
-glucosidases.
In the crystal, two monomers per asymmetric unit related by a
non-crystallographic symmetry were identified. The surface area buried
on the dimer interface is 2,131 Å2 corresponding
to 1,066 Å2 per monomer when the calculation is
performed with the program Crystallography & NMR System (Brünger
et al., 1998
) and the probe diameter is 1.4 Å. The dimer interface is
formed by residues of three
-helices (S266-L281, G282-G291, and
P294-R302) and two loops (N335-L346 and K391-N394). Mutual orientation
of the secondary structure elements within the dimer is indicated in
Figure 2. Most of the monomer contacts in the dimer interface are
represented by aromatic stacking and hydrogen and ionic bonds. No
intermolecular disulfide bridge connects the monomer subunits in the
dimer. An intramolecular disulfide bridge was identified in each
monomer (Fig. 2), and, recently, we have shown that its formation is an essential prerequisite for gaining monomer competence to assemble into
an active dimer (Rotrekl et al., 1999
).
Active Site
The active site is a slot-like structure intruding from the
surface to the barrel core of the protein. The third layer of residues
constituting the barrel interior represents the base of the slot. Slot
walls are formed mainly by four extended loops (I-IV in Fig. 1). The
loops consist of residues N54 through S71 (loop I), Y195 through E221
(loop II), N335 through M376 (loop III), and W452 through V471 (loop
IV). The slot-forming loops represent the sites of the highest
variability in the
-glucosidase family as expected for the sites
participating in the determination of substrate specificity. At the
entrance, the slot is approximately 22 Å long and 8 Å wide. The upper
part of the active site represents a putative aglycone-binding site,
whereas the glycone-binding site is located in the bottom one-half of
the active site slot.
The glycone-binding site is formed by a number of polar and aromatic
residues that are commonly found within carbohydrate recognition sites.
The hydrophobic site of the Glc ring can be stacked onto W452 that is
highly conserved in family 1 of
-glycosidases and represents the
last amino acid residue on the C-terminal end of
-strand 8. For
hydrogen-bonding interactions with the Glc moiety, several conserved
amino acid residues are available in appropriate orientations including
Q33 (N
2 and O
1 H bond to O4 and O3, respectively), H137 (N
2 H
bonds to O3), N185 (N
2 H bonds to O2), and E459 (O
1 and O
2 H
bond to O4 and 06, respectively). It is interesting that an unknown
electron density was observed in the glycone-binding pocket. To
interpret the electron density, enzyme kinetic analysis was employed to
investigate the affinity of the enzyme active site to glycerol, a
cryoprotectant used in crystal diffraction analysis. Glycerol proved to
be a weak competitive inhibitor of Zm-p60.1 (dissociation constant of
an enzyme-inhibitor complex [Ki] = 215 mM). Modeling experiments indicated that the electron density can be interpreted as two glycerol molecules. Electron
densities in substrate-unoccupied active sites were assigned as
glycerol molecules in SAMyr (Burmeister et al., 1997
) and a ZM-Glu1
mutant (Czjzek et al., 2000
), however, without providing independent
experimental evidence to support the assignment.
E186 and E401 Constitute the Catalytic Pair in Zm-p60.1
Multiple alignment using ClustalW program positioned E186 and E401
into the highly conserved TXNEX and ITENG motifs, respectively (not
shown). In Zm-p60.1 structure, the conserved E186 and E401 were found
in the loop regions close to the carboxy-terminal ends of
-strands 4 and 7, respectively. Furthermore, E186 and 401 are in close
proximity
the distance between their carbonyl carbons C
is 4.98 Å and between E186 O
1 and E401
O
2 it is 3.52 Å (Fig. 2). Two conserved Glu
residues located close to the C termini of
-strands 4 and 7 and
separated by a distance of about 5 Å were proposed to function as the
acid/base and nucleophile, respectively, in the 4/7 superfamily of
glycohydrolases (Henrissat et al., 1995
; Jenkins et al., 1995
). Because
Zm-p60.1 belongs to the 4/7 superfamily based on sequence similarities
and crystal structure analysis, E186 and E401 can constitute the
catalytic pair in Zm-p60.1.
The contribution of E186 and E401 to Zm-p60.1 enzyme activity was
investigated using site-directed mutagenesis followed by enzyme kinetic
analysis of the mutants. In (His)6Zm-p60.r, a
recombinant derivative of Zm-p60.1, the Glu residues were changed
individually, in independent experiments, to Asp and Gln residues. The
resulting mutants were produced in E. coli. To exclude
effects of any gross alteration in quaternary structure on enzyme
kinetic analysis, assembly of the mutants into
catalysis-competent dimer structure (Rotrekl et al.,
1999
) was analyzed in soluble bacterial protein extracts using native
PAGE followed by
-glucosidase activity "in-gel" staining, and
immunodetection of the mutants on corresponding western blots. E186D,
E186Q, and E401Q were found in the form of dimers indistinguishable
from the (His)6Zm-p60.r dimer. It was
surprising that the major fraction of E401D migrated at
(His)6Zm-p60.r monomer position (Fig.
3a). Highly sensitive activity
"in-gel" staining based on a fluorogenic substrate
4-methylumbelliferyl
-D-glucopyranoside
(MUG) staining demonstrated a small but detectable enzymatic activity
associated with the dimer form in E186D/Q and E401Q mutants. Detectable
staining associated with expected dimer position in E401D indicated
that a small fraction (below immunostaining detection limit
about 10 ng of protein per band in our assay conditions) of the mutant is
present in the dimeric form and retained substantial enzyme activity.
As expected from our previous experiments (Rotrekl et al., 1999
), there
was no enzyme activity associated with the monomeric form of the mutant
(not shown). In addition to DNA sequencing, the sample homogeneity of
the mutants was demonstrated by operational reversion. The revertants,
Q186E, D186E, Q401E, and D401E, were detected in dimeric form on
western blot (not shown) and were stained "in gel" using a
chromogenic substrate 6-bromo-2-naphtyl
-D-glucopyranoside to an extent
undistinguishable from the (His)6Zm-p60.r dimer
(Fig. 3b).
|
Enzyme kinetic analysis was performed on
(His)6Zm-p60.r and individual mutants purified in
a single step on metal chelate affinity chromatography (MCAC) columns.
The kinetic parameters kcat(WT)/kcat(mut)
and Km of the mutants obtained for the
fluorogenic substrate MUG are presented in Table
II. Km values
are fairly similar to those of the wild-type enzyme for all mutants,
suggesting that the Glu residues are not significantly involved in
substrate binding as expected for the catalytic pair. The dramatic
decrease of kcat observed in the mutant
enzymes E186D/Q and E401Q strongly suggests that these are the
catalytic amino acid residues. The conservative substitution E401D
resulted in a kcat decrease similar to
E401Q when judged on a total enzyme quantity in an assay mixture. However, native PAGE electrophoresis followed by MUG staining demonstrated that the enzyme activity was associated solely with the
dimer form. Western blot followed by immunostaining and densitometry analysis of the purified mutant E401D revealed that only approximately 0.5% of the protein was present as the active dimer in the preparation subjected to the enzyme kinetics analysis. After including a correction for the active component of the protein preparation, only a moderate decrease of kcat in E401D was found
[kcat(WT)/kcat(E401D) = 50 with MUG as a substrate] that is close to the value found in an analogous A. faecalis
-glucosidase nucleophile mutant
[kcat(WT)/kcat(E358D) = 122 with 2',4'-dinitrophenyl
-D-glucopyranoside as a substrate; Withers et
al., 1992
]. Thus, Asp residue can substitute for the Glu residue more
efficiently as a nucleophile, rather than as an acid/base catalyst. In
the extensively characterized A. faecalis
-glucosidase,
replacement of the acid/base Glu residue by a Gly residue (E170G)
resulted in a dramatic reduction of rate of glycosyl enzyme formation
for substrates needing acid catalysis, whereas the rate remained almost
unchanged for substrates not requiring protonic assistance (Wang et
al., 1995
). In Sulfolobus solfataricus
-glycosidase,
substitution of a putative acid/base, E206 identified in an NEP motif,
by Q resulted in a 60-fold decrease in catalytic activity on PNPG
(Moracci et al., 1996
). The more pronounced effect on
kcat observed in the Zm-p60.1 mutant enzyme
E186Q
[kcat(WT)/kcat(E186Q) = 1.5 × 103] might, at least in part, be
account for by methylumbelliferone being a less efficient leaving group
compared with p-nitrophenol.
|
The microenvironments of E186 and E401 are consistent with their
proposed roles in the catalytic step. As a proton donor, E186 is
expected to be protonated in the basic state of the enzyme. Hydrophobic
nature of W138 and T189 located close to O
1
might contribute to the increased pKa
necessary for catalysis at pH 5.5 to 6.0 (the optimum reaction pH
range). O
2 of E186 forms a hydrogen bond with
N
2 of N326. In contrast, E401 is located close
to mostly polar residues (R91, N185, N326, and Y328). Moreover, O
2 of E401 forms a salt bridge with R91, and
O
1 forms two hydrogen bonds with hydroxyl
group of the Y328 and a water molecule (Fig. 4b). Thus, E401 is deprotonated and
therefore available for nucleophilic attack. A similar microenvironment
was reported for the proton donor and the nucleophile in TRCB-Glu
(Barrett et al., 1995
), and for the nucleophile in SAMyr (Burmeister et
al., 1997
).
|
Taken together, the sequence alignments, structure, and site-directed mutagenesis followed by enzyme kinetics prove that E186 and E401 are the acid/base and the nucleophile, respectively, in Zm-p60.1.
E401D Mutation Hinders Dimer Assembly
As mentioned above, native PAGE analysis revealed a remarkable
effect of E401D substitution on the enzyme structure. The
electrophoretic mobility of the mutant on native gels is
indistinguishable from that of (His)6Zm-p60.r
monomer, confirming that the overall fold is retained in the mutant.
However, the dramatically decreased ability of mutant monomer to
assemble into a homodimer suggests that it adopts a distinct
conformational state, an interpretation that is consistent with the
observation that E401D exhibits altered chromatographic behavior
observed during purification. Although (His)6Zm-p60.r, E186D/Q and E401Q bind readily to
a zinc-charged iminodiacetate-POROS-column
(IDA-Zn2+) used routinely for the single-step
purification of the wild type and mutants, the E401D mutant is not
retained by the column to any detectable extent. However, no difference
in chromatographic behavior was observed between E401D and
(His)6Zm-p60.r on a nickel-charged nitrilotriacetate-Sepharose-column (NTA-Ni2+)
allowing single-step purification of E401D (not shown). Lack of E401D
binding to IDA-Zn2+ might be explained if the
proposed change in conformational state causes the His tag on E401D
surface to become less accessible. Because in general the His tag binds
more tightly to NTA-Ni2+ compared with
IDA-Zn2+, the partly exposed His tag could still
efficiently interact with a stronger coordination partner,
NTA-Ni2+. The His tag and E401 are located on the
opposite sides of the (
/
)8 barrel and are
not connected by a common
-strand or
-helix. Thus, the
conformational change extends beyond the
-7 strand and the adjacent
loop carrying the ITENG motif, and is likely to be more complex than a
conformational change in a single element of the secondary structure.
Substitution of the Glu residue in the nucleophile position by an Asp
residue in previously studied glycosidases in the 4/7 superfamily
(including, for example, A. faecalis
-glucosidase,
Withers et al., 1992
; E. coli
-galactosidase, Yuan et
al., 1994
; and Bacillus circulans xylanase, Wakarchuk et
al., 1994
) has not resulted in gross conformational changes detectable
as altered CD spectra, and native PAGE mobility. However, although the
E to Q/N mutants in A. faecalis
-glucosidase, and E to
Q/V mutants in E. coli
-galactosidase exhibited slightly higher or very similar thermal stability compared with the
corresponding wild-type enzymes, all examined E to D mutations exerted
a clear decrease in thermal stability. Inspection of E401
microenvironment clearly indicates also that the E401D mutation in
Zm-p60.1 results in a loss of stabilizing interactions (a hydrogen bond
between E401 and Y328, and a salt bridge between E401 and R91). Earlier studies of peptide models suggested that the process of folding is
guided by interactions that also stabilize the final native structure.
Thus, the distinct conformational state in E401D might be a consequence
of perturbation of interactions that guide folding. It is interesting
that we have recently identified an independent mutation, I404D, in the
ITENG loop that also hinders dimer formation in the same experimental
system (J. Zouhar and B. Brzobohatý, unpublished data).
Though the Zm-p60.1 crystal structure proves that all residues forming
the active center are provided by a single monomer, dimer formation is
an essential prerequisite for activity of the enzyme (Rotrekl et al.,
1999
). Because the dimerization interface and active site are not in
close proximity with each other (Fig. 2c), the reason for the necessity
of dimerization for enzyme activity is not obvious. However, the
dramatic influence of E401D and I404D mutations on the assembly of
catalysis-competent homodimer might represent the first experimental
indication of interactions between the ITENG loop and loops forming the
dimerization area. Independent evidence supporting mutual dependence of
the active site architecture and adoption of dimerization competent
conformation of loops forming the dimerization area comes from our
earlier analysis of C205A/S/R/D and C211A/S/R/D mutants. The mutations
resulted in a dramatic reduction of monomer competence to assemble into
dimers, and reduced catalytic efficiency of the enzyme (Rotrekl et al.,
1999
), though the disulfide bridge is neither a part of the catalytic
center nor dimerization area (Fig. 2). However, the enzyme structure analysis revealed that formation of the disulfide bridge is involved in
precise positioning of F193 and F200, two of four aglycone-binding site
key residues involved in enzyme-aglycone interactions (Figs. 2 and 4).
Thus, conformational changes within the active site induced by diverse
mutations seems to uncover a link between fine tuning of formation of
catalysis competent structure of the active site and
dimerization-competent architecture of the monomer-monomer interface in
the course of dimer assembly. Structure analysis of E401D and I404D
mutants could represent an important step in uncovering structural
principles underlying mutual dependence of dimer formation and recovery
of enzyme activity in Zm-p60.1 and related
-glucosidases. The
experiments addressing this issue are in progress.
F193 Determines Both Substrate Affinity and Catalytic Rate
To obtain preliminary information on the nature of the molecular
determination of Zm-p60.1 specificity toward substrate aglycone moiety,
a preliminary attempt to locate putative amino acid residues forming
the aglycone binding site was performed on a refined homology-based model of the three-dimensional structure of Zm-p60.1 constructed earlier (Rotrekl et al., 1999
). Inspection of the active site slot
showed that its upper part, the proposed aglycone-binding site, is
formed mainly by hydrophobic residues. The limited accuracy of the
model did not justify any detailed molecular docking that could
identify residues involved in enzyme-substrate interactions. However,
F193 appeared as a key determinant of the width of the slot-like
aglycone-binding site, and therefore a potential determinant of
aglycone specificity. A similar, though less convincing prediction could be made for M258, which appeared as a width codeterminant located
opposite F193. Later, solving of the crystal structure led to
confirmation of the proposed role for F193, and facilitated reliable
interpretations of kinetic data obtained in F193 mutants. Though the
prediction made for M258 turned out not to be precise, M258 is just
adjacent to the residues determining the narrowest region of the
aglycone-binding site. Therefore, kinetic analysis of M258 mutants
brings a support for highly localized character of the "bottleneck"
region of the slot-like aglycone-binding site deduced from the crystal
structure (Fig. 4).
The functional contribution of F193 and M258 to catalytic activity was investigated by site-directed mutagenesis followed by enzyme kinetic analysis. In (His)6Zm-p60.r, F193 was changed in separate experiments to I, W, and Y. In a similar manner, M258 was replaced by I, F, and V. The resulting mutants were produced in E. coli. Native PAGE analysis of individual soluble bacterial protein extracts confirmed formation of a catalysis-competent dimer structure in all investigated mutants (not shown). For enzyme kinetic analysis, the mutants were purified by single step MCAC chromatography. The kinetic parameters Km and kcat obtained for the chromogenic substrate PNPG are summarized in Table III. Although systematic increase in Km in all the F193 mutants supported the proposed role of F193 in determination of the enzyme substrate affinity, distinct decreases in kcat in the individual F193 mutants indicated a yet unrecognized function of F193. Kinetic parameters of M258 mutants displayed no or only moderate changes compared with the wild type.
|
Prompted by the dramatic effect of F193I on the Zm-p60.1 specificity
constant
(kcat/Km) with
PNPG, we focused on a detailed analysis of the F193 microenvironment in
the Zm-p60.1 crystal structure. Detailed inspection of the structure
followed by molecular docking revealed that the aglycone interaction
with the slot-like aglycone-binding site is largely determined by W373
stacking interactions with the aglycone aromatic system, and van der
Waals interactions with the edges of the phenyl rings provided by F193,
F200, and F461 (Fig. 4). The W373 orientation favorable for stacking
interactions is stabilized by a hydrogen bond between
N
1 of W373 and water that is firmly positioned
by additional hydrogen bonds with E466 and Y468. Therefore, E466 and
Y468 can contribute indirectly to substrate specificity and catalytic
efficiency. Proper positioning of F193, F200, and F461 appears to be
stabilized by a large hydrophobic cluster formed by F51, W48, W138,
F190, and W460 (not shown). In addition, the disulfide bridge between
C205 and C211 stabilizes the loop containing F193 and F200 (Fig. 2). It
is interesting that we have found a dramatic drop in enzyme activity in
mutants C205S and C211A/S (Rotrekl et al., 1999
). Though the drop might be explained in part by the observed decreased ability of these mutants to form the catalysis-competent dimer (Rotrekl et al., 1999
),
the structural analysis presented here suggests that the decrease in
catalytic efficiency may partly be due to loss of F193 and F200
position stabilization.
The molecular docking together with increase in
Km in F193/I/W/Y mutants presented above
support a recent assignment of F193 as a determinant of enzyme affinity
toward glucosides with an aromatic aglycone that was based on
structural analysis of inactive mutant enzyme-substrate complex (Czjzek
et al., 2000
). It was unexpected that our kinetic results clearly
demonstrate that the dramatic drop in the F193I specificity constant is
caused mainly by drop in kcat. Based on
this novel finding, structure inspection allowed us to propose that the
F193-aglycone-W373 interaction represents a major contribution to the
positioning of the glucosidic bond in an orientation favorable for
attack by E186 and E401. Therefore, the interaction is expected to
codetermine catalytic rate of the enzyme. In contrast, glycone-enzyme
interactions do not seem to contribute to the appropriate positioning
of the glucosidic bond to large extent. Previous enzyme kinetic
analysis indicated that the ground state of the glycone-binding pocket
is complementary to Glc in the half chair conformation rather than the
chair conformation. Glc was a much weaker competitive inhibitor
compared with D-glucono-1,5-lactone, which has a
half-chair conformation and inhibits the enzyme by acting as a
transition state analog (Babcock and Esen, 1994
; J. Zouhar, J. Vévodová, J. Marek, J. Damborský, X.-D. Su, and B. Brzobohatý, unpublished data). Thus, the narrow slot of the aglycone-binding site formed by F193, F200, F461, and W373 appears to
be a stereochemical determinant of the interaction strength (Fig. 4).
Although W373 is highly conserved among family 1
-glucosidases, F193
is highly variable (Fig. 1), indicating that a residue at this position
is likely to be involved in fine-tuning substrate specificity and
reaction rate. This is consistent with the fact that the F193I mutation
caused approximately 100-fold decrease in the specificity constant
(kcat/Km) with
PNPG (Table III).
The analysis of the topological consequences of F193I substitution in
Zm-p60.1 crystal structure correlates well with the dramatic effect on
kcat. When F193I substitution is modeled,
the width of the slot increases from 7.3 Å in WT to 8.5 Å. An even more dramatic increase is found for mouth opening (Table
IV), which determines the cross section
of the slot at the respective position more precisely (Lee and
Richards, 1971
; Connolly, 1983
). One can hypothesize intuitively that
the increased cross section of the slot might allow higher freedom of
movement of the aglycone moiety; that in turn would result in decreased
average time for which the glucosidic bond is located in the
orientation favorable for attack by the catalytic pair. As a
consequence, the rate of glucosidic bond cleavage will decrease, and
reaction rate represented by kcat will
drop. Consistent with this hypothesis, in F193W, the decrease in width
and mouth opening that can be calculated for the mutant correlate with
a slight increase in reaction rate. Increased
Km found in F193W might reflect steric
constraints connected with substrate penetration into, and
accommodation within, the active center due to narrowing of the slot.
Although the topological parameters in F193Y reach values between WT
and F193W (Table IV), kcat decreased to
62% of WT (Tables III). The kcat decrease
might reflect the different chemical nature of the atoms forming
contacts with the aglycone and the residue at position 193. Although in WT and F193W an H atom of the respective aromatic rings form the van
der Waals interactions with the aglycone, the more polar H of a
hydroxyl group is involved in the interaction in F193Y.
|
The crucial role of a precise stereochemical architecture of the aglycone binding site in the region formed by F193, F200, F461, and W373 for enzyme activity becomes even more evident when modeled topological alterations and kinetic parameters are compared for mutations in a position close but clearly outside this region. As mentioned above, analysis of the homology-based model of the three-dimensional structure of Zm-p60.1 suggested that the width of the slot in the aglycone-binding site might be determined by F193 and M258 located opposite each other along the sides of the slot. Therefore, three mutations in position 258 were constructed in addition to mutations in position 193. In all the mutants analyzed, the most dramatic increase in mouth opening was calculated for M258V mutant (Table IV). However, kinetic analysis of the mutant revealed only a moderate decrease in kcat (Table III). On the other hand, only minor changes in mouth opening calculated for M258I are accompanied by a clearly decreased specificity constant. No unambiguous solution for mouth opening calculation can be obtained for M258F precluding any correlation with kinetic data obtained for M258F. The available data are consistent with the location of M258 at the edge of the aglycone-binding site.
A systematic assessment by site-directed mutagenesis, enzyme kinetic analysis, and computer modeling of the relative contributions of the individual residues identified in the active center to substrate specificity and catalytic rate remains a challenge for subsequent studies.
| |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Site-Directed Mutagenesis
The GeneEditor in vitro site-directed mutagenesis system
(Promega, Madison, WI) was used to introduce the desired mutations into
(His)6Zm-p60.r, a recombinant
Zm-p60.1 derivative lacking the plastid targeting
sequence [the N-terminal sequence of (His)6Zm-p60.r is
Mr(H)6GMAS, the last residue
of which corresponds to the Ser determined at the N terminus of
Zm-p60.1 isolated from maize (Zea mays) coleoptiles;
Brzohohatý et al., 1993
], in
pRSET::Zm-p60.r as described earlier (Rotrekl
et al., 1999
; Zouhar et al., 1999
). The resulting mutants are
designated pRSET::Zm-p60.rm. The mutagenic oligonucleotides were as follows: E186D,
5'-GTCTGGGGGTCATTAAAGG-3'; E186Q,
5'-TCTGGGGCTGATTAAAGGT-3'; E401D,
5'-GATTCCGTTGTCCGTGATG-3'; E401Q,
5'-TTCCGTTCTGCGTGATGTAG-3'; F193I,
5'-TCCGTAGGAAATGGAAGTAAATG-3'; F193Y,
5'-TCCGTAGGAATAGGAAGTAA-3'; F193W,
5'-TCCGTAGGACCAGGAAGTAAATG-3'; M258I,
5'-GCACACGACCTATTACGTCAAAC-3'; M258F,
5'-GCACACGACCAAATACGTCAAAC-3'; and M258V,
5'-GCACACGACCCACTACGTCAAAC-3' (the changed nucleotides are underlined). Mutations were confirmed by DNA sequencing. The site-directed mutagenesis resulted in
pRSET(AmpRM)::Zm-p60.rm, where
AmpRM is modified/enhanced ampicillin resistance.
D/Q186E and D/Q401E revertants were generated in an analogous way using individual pRSET::Zm-p60.rm as templates. The codon GAA (Glu) was introduced into positions 186 and 401 by oligonucleotides (5'-AAATGTCTGGGGTT-CATTAAAGGTCAA-3' and 5'-CCGATTCCGTTTTCCGT-GATGTAGATAG-3', respectively). The presence of GAA enabled unequivocal revertant identification because E186 and E401 are encoded by GAG in (His)6Zm-p60.r.
Expression and Purification of (His)6Zm-p60.rm
The mutants were expressed in the Escherichia
coli strain BL21(DE3) pLysS as described earlier
(Kuderová et al., 1999
; Zouhar et al., 1999
). Single-step
purification on MCAC columns (POROS MC/M peak column 4.6 × 100 mm, BioCAD workstation, PerSeptive, Framingham, MA) was facilitated by
His tag engineered at the N termini of (His)6Zm-p60.r and
the mutants (Zouhar et al., 1999
). Elution was triggered by EDTA, the
purified protein preparation was diafiltered against water, and used
directly for kinetic and electrophoretic analysis. Purity of the
mutants was higher than 95% as determined by SDS-PAGE followed by
Coomassie Blue staining and densitometry.
Electrophoresis and Western Blotting
Native PAGE was performed in 10% (w/v) gels (Laemmli,
1970
) followed by either activity "in-gel" staining (zymograms) or
semidry western blotting. Zymograms were developed with
6-bromo-2-naphtyl
-D-glucopyranoside as a substrate and
Fast Blue BB as a coupling dye (Esen and Cokmus, 1990
). A fluorogenic
substrate MUG was employed when increased zymogram sensitivity was
desirable (Jefferson et al., 1987
). Protein transfer on
polyvinylidene difluoride membrane (Immobillon P,
Millipore, Bedford, IN) was performed according to Towbin (1979)
.
Positions of dimer and/or monomer forms of (His)6Zm-p60.rm were visualized by an alkaline phosphatase-mediated immunostaining procedure (Blake et al., 1984
). Anti-Zm-p60 polyclonal antibodies were
raised in rabbits against recombinant (His)6Zm-p60.r
produced in E. coli. Anti-rabbit-IgG antibody,
conjugated to alkaline phosphatase, was from Sigma (Deisenhofen, Germany).
Enzyme and Protein Assays
Enzyme activity was assayed using MUG and PNPG as the
fluorogenic and chromogenic substrates, respectively (Babcock and Esen, 1994
; Rotrekl et al., 1999
). Protein concentration was determined according to Bradford (1976)
using protein assay (Bio-Rad Laboratories, Hercules, CA) and bovine serum albumin as a standard.
X-Ray Crystallography
Diffraction data with single crystal of
(His)6Zm-p60.r was collected as reported previously
(Vévodová et al., 2001
). In brief, the crystals of
recombinant protein grew from 20% to 25% (w/v) PEG 4000, 0.1 M citrate buffer, pH 5.3 to 5.9, and 0.2 M ammonium acetate at room temperature and the data were collected at
100.0 K with cryoprotectant 20% (w/v) PEG 4000 and 5% (v/v) glycerol
and wavelength
= 0.9420 Å at the crystallographic beamline BL711 at the MAX-II synchrotron in Lund (Sweden). Data were processed by DENZO and SCALEPACK packages (Otwinowski and Minor, 1997
). The
Zm-p60.1 structure was solved by molecular replacement by AMoRe
(Navaza, 1994
) with the coordinates of the TRCB-Glu (Protein Data Bank
entry 1CBG, Barrett et al., 1995
) as a model. The model was refined
first by rigid body refinement, by several steps of the
crystallographic refinement including the simulated annealing, and
finally by simulated annealing and restrained maximum-likelihood methods. All calculations were performed with Crystallography & NMR
System (Brünger et al., 1998
). Model inspection and rebuilding was carried out using program O (Jones et al., 1991
). The final model
contained 7,943 non-hydrogen protein atoms and 909 water molecules and
converged at R and Rfree (Brünger, 1992
) 16.9% and
23.0%. No
cut-off was used during the refinement. The main-chain dihedral angles of all residues are within energetically allowed regions of the Ramachandran plot
85.6% of all residues lie in the
most favored regions and the rest are in additional allowed regions.
Data statistics are summarized in Table I.
Coordinates
The atomic coordinates of the refined model have been deposited at the Protein Data Bank (Rutgers, NJ) with reference code 1HXJ.
Molecular Modeling
The enzyme-substrate complexes of Zm-p60 with MUG and PNPG were
prepared using the molecular modeling package InsightII (Biosym/MSI Accelrys; www.accelrys.com). The substrate molecules were built in
InsightII and optimized using AM1 semi-empirical quantum mechanical calculations. Polar hydrogens were added to the protein structure using
the WHATIF 5.0 program package (Vriend, 1990
). Starting models of
enzyme-substrate complexes were constructed manually according to
experimental structures of enzyme-substrate and enzyme-inhibitor complexes (Czjzek et al., 2000
) and refined by energy minimization using 100 steps of steepest descent and 500 steps of conjugate gradient
with consistent valence force field of Discover95.0/3.0 (Biosym/MSI Accelrys).
| |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
We wish to thank Dr. Jana Klánová (Department of
Functional Genomics and Proteomics, Masaryk University, Brno, Czech
Republic) for DNA sequencing and Dr. Hana Kone
ná
(Department of Functional Genomics and Proteomics, Masaryk University)
for oligonucleotide synthesis. Anti-(His)6Zm-p60.r
antibodies were prepared in cooperation with the Veterinary Research
Institute (Brno, Czech Republic). We wish to thank Dr. Ian Moore
(Department of Plant Sciences, University of Oxford) and Kiran
Nagavalli Subbana, MSc (Department of Functional Genomics and
Proteomics, Masaryk University), for critically reading the manuscript.
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Received August 10, 2001; accepted August 20, 2001.
1 This work was supported by the Ministry of Education of the Czech Republic (grant nos. VS96096 and MSM143100008), by the INCO-Copernicus Program (grant no. ERB3512-PL966135), by the National Science Foundation, U.S. (grant no. INT-9600462), by the Socrates Erasmus Free Movers and Swedish Institute (grants to J.V.), and by the Swedish Foundation for Strategic Research and Structural Biology Network (support to X.-D.S.).
2 These authors contributed equally to the paper.
* Corresponding author; e-mail brzoboha{at}ibp.cz; fax 420-5-41211293.
Article, publication date, and citation information can be found at www.plantphysiol.org/cgi/doi/10.1104/pp.010712.
| |
LITERATURE CITED |
|---|
|
|
|---|
era I, Abdallah F, Palme K, Brzobohatý B
(1999)
Expression, single-step purification, and matrix-assisted refolding of a maize cytokinin glucoside-specific beta-glucosidase.
Eur J Biochem
266: 1056-1065[ISI][Medline]